2024 Long Island, New York Tomato U-Pick Farms and Orchards - PickYourOwn.org

Tomato U-Pick Orchards in Long Island, New York in 2024, by county

Below are the U-Pick orchards and farms for tomatoes that we know of in this area.

Not all areas of a state have tomatoes farms that are open to the public. If you know of any others, please tell us using the add a farm form!

Remember to always check with the farm's own website or Facebook page before you go - or call or email them if they don't have a website or Facebook page. Conditions at the farms and crops can change literally overnight, so if you want to avoid a wasted trip out there - check with the farm directly before you go! If I cannot reach them, I DON'T GO!

PLEASE report closed farms, broken links and incorrect info using the "Report Corrections" form below.

New! As inflation remains high, see this page for reliable (tested) brands of generic canning lids at lower costs, and cost-saving measures for getting fruit and vegetables and home canning.
 If you are having a hard time finding canning lids, I've used these, and they're a great price & ship in 2 days.

New! Road tripping and camping is a great way to have a fun, safe and inexpensive family trip. The national and state parks and monuments are open, and campgrounds usually cost between $10 and $40 per night. September to November is the best camping weather.  See our new website Road Tripping and Camping.com for tips, tricks, guides, checklists and info about parks, monuments and other places to visit.

New! We just went live with our latest website, FunFactoryTours.com - As they name implies, you can find a fun factory tour, including chocolate, automobiles, historical forts and sites, famous buildings, Active Federal facilities even fun geology: like fossils and volcanic areas

Suffolk County

• Bhavana Blueberries - Certified Organic, blueberries, cucumbers, herbs or spices, melons, summer squash, tomatoes, other vegetables, watermelons, porta-potties are available, picnic area, weddings and wedding parties, group reservations
  4395 Hortons Lane, Southold, NY 11971. Phone: (516) 241-3508. Email: amoshe@bhavanaberries.com. Open: Thursday to Sunday from 10 am to 5 pm from July 11 to Early September, Depending on berry availability. Directions: We are located in Southold on the North Fork of Long Island. Just North of Sound Avenue on Hortons Lane. We are 15 minutes past Riverhead and it\'s a beautiful drive!. . Click here for a map and directions. Payment: Cash, Visa, MasterCard.
  Bhavana Blueberries Facebook page. . Alternate Phone: (646) 284-4087 Thursday to Sunday from 10 am to 5 pm from July 11 to Early September, (Depending on berry availability)We are located in Southold on the North Fork of Long Island. Just North of Sound Avenue on Hortons Lane. We are 15 minutes past Riverhead and it's a beautiful drive! Bhavana Berries is a 30+ acre organic blueberry orchard located on the North Fork of Long Island. From July to early September, the farm is open to the public for U-Pick blueberries. In addition to blueberries, we grow organic garlic, shallots, and a variety of other vegetables that are available at our farmstand in front of the farm. Founded in 2011, Bhavana Berries inherited a sod farm and spent the next 2 years rehabilitating the soil. In 2013, our first blueberry bushes were planted using organic and sustainable agricultural practices. Committed to cultivating a healthy ecosystem for our blueberry bushes, we do all of our weeding and picking by hand and add organic matter to the soil via wood chips and organic fertilizer. By 2016, were certified organic by NOFA-NY. (UPDATED: June 17, 2016) (ADDED: May 31, 2015)
• Doug Cooper - U pick vegetables: tomatoes, melons, cucumbers, beans, peppers, eggplants, okra.
  2200 Breakwater Road, Mattituck, NY 11952. Phone: 631-298-5195. Click here for a map and directions. (UPDATED: September 09, 2016)
• Fritz Lewin Farms - apples, broad beans, corn (sweet), eggplants, pumpkins, summer squash, winter squash, strawberries, tomatoes, other vegetables, Other fruit or veg, and prepicked produce
  1989 Sound Avenue, Baiting Hollow, NY 11933. Phone: 631-727-3346. Directions: Take exit 71 off the l.i.e \(Long Island Expressway\) Make left off the exit onto Edwards Ave. Go straight down Edwards Ave. about 4 miles till you get to the corner of Sound Avenue, make left onto Sound Ave. then we are 14 mile down on the left side. \(BIG RED BARN\) . Click here for a map and directions. Payment: Cash, only. 8 am to 4 pm for pick your own and 8 am to 6 pm for the farm stand; 7 days a week but CALL BEFORE YOU GO - if crops aren't ready, they appear to close for the dayTake exit 71 off the l.i.e (Long Island Expressway) Make left off the exit onto Edwards Ave. Go straight down Edwards Ave. about 4 miles till you get to the corner of Sound Avenue, make left onto Sound Ave. then we are 1/4 mile down on the left side. (BIG RED BARN) See comments about this farm here!
• Hodun Farms - strawberries, tomatoes, peppers, eggplants,
  4070 Middle Country Road, Calverton, NY . Phone: 631-369-3533. Email: hodunfarms@optonline.net. Open: June-October 7 days a week 8 am to 6 pm; be sure to call or email before going. Click here for a map and directions. Payment: Cash, only. In June we have pick your own strawberries. From August to October, we have pick your own tomatoes, peppers, and eggplant (these pick by the bushel only).
• Krupski's Vegetable & Pumpkin Farm - U-pick peas and sugar snap peas, tomatoes, pumpkins and peppers
  38030 Route 25, Peconic, NY 11958. Phone: 631-734-6847. Email: kelloggrox@hotmail.com. Click here for a map and directions. Krupski's Vegetable & Pumpkin Farm Alternate phone: 631-734-7841. . 8 am to 7 pm, Daily, About June-November. U-pick peas and sugar snap peas June-early July; Tomatoes and peppers approx. mid-July; u-pick pumpkins from vine, corn maze, hayrides, haunted barn, haunted hayrides in October; farm fresh produce at all timesTake the Long Island Expressway (Rte. 495) to exit 73 (last exit). Continue east on Rte. 58 which becomes Rte. 25. From the exit it is approximately 16 miles to Peconic. We are on the south side of the road at the "Peconic" sign across from Pindar Vineyards.
• Lenny Bruno Farms - eggplant, pumpkins, peppers, tomatoes, other vegetables, farm market, gift shop, snacks and refreshment stand, picnic area
  7740 Wading River Road, Manorville, NY 11949. Phone: 631-591-3592. Email: farmstand@lennybrunofarms.com. Open: mid July to 1st frost. Directions: at the corner of exit 69 off the LIE and Wading River Road. Please call 631-591-3592 for help. . Click here for a map and directions. Payment: Cash, only.
  Lenny Bruno Farms Facebook page. Fax: 631-591-3594 We are considering doing pick your own strawberries so Email us if you are interested. Our pick your own generally starts early-mid August and includes bell peppers, long hots, cheese peppers, hot cherry peppers, sweet cherry peppers, fryers, white peppers, plum tomatoes, beefsteak tomatoes, black eggplant, little finger eggplant, flat beans and fall pumpkins. In the Fall, our pumpkin fields are inviting to children of all ages. This season also brings cauliflower, Brussels sprouts, the fall squashes, cabbage and potatoes! See comments about this farm here!(UPDATED: June 15, 2023, JBS)
• Lewin Farms - apples, blackberries, blueberries, eggplants, nectarines, peaches, peppers, pumpkins, raspberries (red), raspberries (yellow), raspberries (black), strawberries, tomatoes,
  812 Sound Avenue, Wading River, NY 11792. Phone: 631-929-4327. Open: PYO fields open until 4:30pm , 9 am to 4:30 pm Subject to season and availability, weather permitting; All PYO usually open both weekend days, call ahead, especially for weekdays, depends on crop and year; Farm stand is open everyday except Tuesday 9-5pm. Directions: LIE exit 68 North William Floyd Parkway, right to 25A, 3 lights, Left onto Sound Avenue, 1 mile on right 4 miles to Sound Ave., 14 mile on left - Note, a visitor says the pick your own apples are on Fresh Pond Avenue, not Sound Avenue. The farm is huge and apparently covers several towns, including Calverton and Wading river. . Click here for a map and directions. Payment: Cash, only.
  Lewin Farms Facebook page. PYO fields open until 4:30pm , 9 am to 4:30 pm Subject to season and availability, weather permitting; All PYO usually open both weekend days, call ahead, especially for weekdays, depends on crop and year; Farm stand is open everyday (except Tuesday) 9-5pm. Picking updates: Click here for picking updatesLIE exit 68 North William Floyd Parkway, right to 25A, 3 lights, Left onto Sound Avenue, 1 mile on right 4 miles to Sound Ave., 1/4 mile on left - Note, a visitor says the pick your own apples are on Fresh Pond Avenue, not Sound Avenue. The farm is huge and apparently covers several towns, including Calverton and Wading river From Late July-October we have our own Roasted Corn for sale on the weekends at the farm stand. We were the first pick your own farm on Long Island, and we are continuing this tradition with pick your own strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, peaches, tomatoes, peppers, eggplants, apples, corn maze, pumpkins and cut your own Christmas trees. They also carry a full line of farm fresh, locally grown fruits and vegetables at their huge farmstand. Facebook page. Typical dates for PYO are: Strawberries in June, Blueberries in July; Peaches from Middle of July through the middle of September, Tomatoes, Peppers, Eggplant in late August through late October, Apples from late August through late October, Pumpkins from the end of September through October, and Christmas trees from day after Thanksgiving to Christmas. Farm stand opens Memorial Day Weekend and the normal business hours for farm market store are 9 am to 5 pm for Spring, Summer and into October. November (closes at 4pm). Our farm stand offers a full line of fresh fruits and vegetables. Many of these are grown on our farm. We also get other local Long Island produce and honey from nearby farms to bring you the freshest quality locally grown produce possible. They now have an ATM machine in the farm stand for your convenience.
  Comments from a visitor on June 13, 2011: "After calling both May's and Lewin's, I found that neither farm is offering pick-your-own strawberries this year, although May's is selling strawberries at their stand."/span>See comments about this farm here!
• May's Farm Stand - strawberries, peas, peppers, tomatoes, pumpkins, string beans, eggplants,
  6361 Route 25A, Wading River, NY 11792. Phone: 631-929-6654. Email: info@maysfarmny.com. Open: 9 am to 6 pm, daily May-October. Directions: Mays Farm is located on Rt. 25A in Wading River, about 1 mile east of William Floyd Parkway. Take the LIE \(Rt. 495\) to exit 68 William Floyd Parkway north , or take Sunrise Highway to exit 58 north William Floyd Parkway. Go north on William Floyd Parkway to the end \(RT. 25A\) Turn right on Rt. 25A and we are one mile up on the right hand side. U-pick strawberries in late May and June; and peas start in late June; peppers, tomatoes, string beans and eggplant August and September; fresh far - truncated. . Click here for a map and directions. . Alternate Phone: 631-965-3391 Mays Farm is located on Rt. 25A in Wading River, about 1 mile east of William Floyd Parkway. Take the LIE (Rt. 495) to exit 68 William Floyd Parkway north , or take Sunrise Highway to exit 58 north William Floyd Parkway. Go north on William Floyd Parkway to the end (RT. 25A) Turn right on Rt. 25A and we are one mile up on the right hand side. U-pick strawberries in late May and June; and peas start in late June; peppers, tomatoes, string beans and eggplant August and September; fresh farm produce, call to confirm. Come and spend a few hours at the farm with your family. Go out into our pumpkin patch and find the perfect pumpkin. We offer tractor drawn hayrides and challenge you to try to find your way through May's Amazing Corn Maze. In our fields, we grow many varieties of fresh fruits and vegetables, including strawberries, sweet corn, tomatoes, peppers, eggplants, melons, cucumbers, squash, string beans, pumpkins, and much more. We sell these at our farm stand 7 days a week, as well as at two local farmers markets from July through October. One of these is located in Port Jefferson, at the ferry parking lot on Thursdays from 10-4. The other is in Patchogue, on Montauk Highway, 500 feet west of RT. 112. This market is located in the 7-11 parking lot, on the north side of the street on Fridays from 8-1. We accept Farmers Market Nutrition Program Checks, as well as cash, at both farmers markets. In June we open our fields for Strawberry and Sweet Pea Picking In October, we feature Pumpkin Picking, along with a corn maze, hayrides, pony rides and much more.
  Comments from a visitor on June 13, 2011: "After calling both May's and Lewin's, I found that neither farm is offering pick-your-own strawberries this year, although May's is selling strawberries at their stand.

 

Tomatoes

Tomato Picking Tips, Recipes and Information

Pick tomatoes that are firm and free of blemishes. Cracking is common in very hot weather, especially after a rain, and if you intend to use the tomatoes within 1 day, that will be ok.

During hot summer weather, pick the tomatoes when they have a healthy pink/red (or yellow or orange depending on the variety) color and let them finish the last day or two of ripening indoors. Tomatoes do not need to be in the sunlight in order to ripen. If you have green fruit on the plants in the fall when frost is approaching, pick the tomatoes and store them in a cool, dark place to ripen.

Tomato Varieties

In general paste or Roma-type tomatoes are the best to using for canning, as they have thicker, meatier walls and far less water. And cherry tomatoes are the worst to use, as they are mostly water.  But you can use any type you can get hold of.  You may just have to cook them down longer to boil off excess water.  See our Master list of tomato varieties

Growing tomatoes

• Master list of tomato varieties
• Master List of Heirloom Tomato Varieties
• How to Grow Tomatoes in Your Yard or Patio - Everything you need to know
• Detailed directions to starting tomatoes from seed
• Master List of Roma and Paste Tomato Varieties for the Home Garden
• Master list of disease-resistant tomato varieties
• Tomato plant diseases

Canning, Freezing, Drying, Preserving Tomatoes and more!

Below are links to pages with easy and reliable directions about how to can, preserve, freeze and make other goodies from tomatoes.  Some of these require a Pressure Canner to prevent potential spoilage and food poisoning, due to the low acid content of the food.  For others, you can use a water bath canner OR a Pressure Canner.  I've noted what's required for each, below, following each entry, with
W for water bath,
P for Pressure canner, and
W, P for either may be used!

And don't miss: Answers to common tomato canning problems and see this page about what to do with your unripe green tomatoes!

Prepping tomatoes

• How to quickly and easily remove tomato skins

Canning tomatoes (in water bath canners )

• How to can tomatoes using a water bath canner - W
• Diced, chopped or crushed tomatoes - W
• Bruschetta - W
• Tomato sauce - W
• Tomato paste - W
• Barbecue sauce (BBQ sauce) - W
• Chili sauce from your own tomatoes and peppers - W
• Diced, chopped or crushed tomatoes - W
• Tomato Preserves- W
• Tomato salsa - W
• Spaghetti sauce - without meat - W, P
• Spiced Green tomatoes- W
• Pickled Green Tomatoes - W - another pickled green tomato recipe, this one sweet
• Ketchup.. or if you prefer... How to make catsup - W, P
• NEW! SUPER-EASY homemade ketchup recipe - W
• Salsa from your unripe, GREEN tomatoes! - W
• Tomatillo salsa - W
• How to make roasted tomatoes, boiling water bath canner version - W

Canning Tomatoes in Pressure canners

• Canned tomatoes using a Pressure Canner - P
• Baked  Beans With Tomato or Molasses Sauce - P
• Canning your own chili con carne (with meat) - P
• How to make roasted tomatoes, pressure canner version - P
• Spaghetti sauce - with meat  - P
• Stewed tomatoes - P
• Tomato soup or tomato-basil soup - P
• Tomato sauce - P
• Tomato juice - P
• Tomato juice, like V8 - P

Freezing Tomatoes

• How to freeze tomatoes from you garden or the farm; for that fresh taste this winter!
• Space-saving prepping and freezing extra tomatoes from your garden to can later

Drying tomatoes

• NEW! How to make Sun-Dried Tomatoes
• Food drying basics and principles
• How to dry your own herbs
• Food Dehydrators - models, specs and pricing information

Ripening green tomatoes in your garage or basement

If you want to bring your green tomatoes indoors before a freeze in the Fall, and ripen them, see:

• How to ripen your green garden tomatoes indoors in the Fall and Winter.

And if you'd like to start you own tomatoes from seed (you can save a small fortune and grow the heirloom varieties you like) see this page for easy directions for growing your own tomato plants from seed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Canning, Freezing and Preserving Tomatoes

• See this page for answers to many common questions about tomatoes.

 

Other Local Farm Products (Honey, Horses, Milk, Meat, Eggs, Etc.)
(NOT pick-your-own, unless they are also listed above)

• Farm markets and roadside stands
• Local Honey Finder
• Local Meat, Milk and Eggs
• Venues: Farms, Wineries, Orchards for your event, wedding or party
• Easter egg hunts
• Children"s consignment sales
• Fruit and vegetable festivals
• Winery tours and wine tastings
• Horse rides, stables, lessons, trails
• Maple Syrup farms and sugarworks
• Bed & Breakfasts on Farms, Wineries, Ranches and Orchards
• Pumpkin patches
• Corn mazes
• Zombie Paintball venues
• Christmas Tree Farms & lots
• Environmental resources
• Consumer fraud information
• Wholesale food sources
• Resources for Farmers